A political critique of all sides from an average Joe who is tired of politics-as-usual. It has become the status quo in Washington to say and do whatever it takes to get elected and stay in office. The media covers the he-said-she-said instead of reporting on the real issues. We, the people, are the only ones left to hold them accountable. Join me in holding our elected representatives, and those who aspire to become such, to a higher standard.
This one has been on the blogs for a while now, and now that the McCain campaign has this ad out, it's past time I officially called out Palin for her "Bridge-to-nowhere" claim:
Ketchikan desires a better way to reach the airport, but the $398 million bridge is not the answer. Despite the work of our congressional delegation, we are about $329 million short of full funding for the bridge project, and it’s clear that Congress has little interest in spending any more money on a bridge between Ketchikan and Gravina Island. Much of the public's attitude toward Alaska bridges is based on inaccurate portrayals of the projects here. But we need to focus on what we can do, rather than fight over what has happened.
Hardly sounds like "Thanks, but no thanks" to me.
Polifact rates her claim as "barely true." I think they are being kind.
The surge is the issue that hurts the Obama campaign the most, in my opinion. He is asked about it in almost every interview, and he is forced to try to explain how the surge worked, but somehow he was still right.
I almost felt sorry for Obama, struggling to make this point on "This Week with George Stephanopoulos":
George: "But given all you just said, how do you escape the logic... you said that we succeeded in Iraq beyond our wildest dreams... how do you escape the logic that that means John McCain was right about the surge?"
Obama: "You, it's interesting to me why people are so focused on what's happened in the last year and half, and not in the last five."
George: "No, granted, you think you made the right decision going in... but about the surge."
Obama: "But they're connected George, and here's why. My whole premise has always been that it was a distraction for us to go into Iraq. Once we were there we had to make the best of a bad situation."
George: "And didn't the surge do that?"
Obama: "And what I have said is, at the time that we made the decision to go into the surge, that it did not address the underlying problem of the unwillingness of the Iraqis, to overcome their political differences and reconcile."
George: "15 out of the 18 benchmarks were met."
Obama: "And to provide the kind of strategy that would allow us to move forward. That wasn't part of the package on the surge. So, if the question is, has the surge done much better than we expected, in combination with these other factors, then the answer is yes, and I've said this repeatedly. But if the question is what was the judgement to be made at the time it was put forward by the Bush administration. My choice, and John McCain's choice was, are we going to continue to give George Bush a blank check without any strategy for political reconciliation, or are we going to try to pressure this administration to come up with a more coherent, cohesive plan for how we were going to wind this war down."
I'm not sure I understand his point (maybe it's too nuanced for a feeble mind like mine to understand), but what I think I heard was basically this:
"Yes, the surge worked. But it was still the right decision not to trust that it was going to work, given the fact that it was promoted by Bush, who is always wrong about everything. So McCain was wrong to think that the surge was going to work, even though it did. It was bad judgment to think that it would work. The only correct judgment to be made at the time was that we should begin to wind the war down (ie. decreasing troop numbers), instead of surging in more troops, even though it seems now that surging in more troops actually helped us wind the war down more rapidly. That result was not predictable, and therefore it was wrong the predict it, even if it turned out to be true."
Sure... OK. I guess that's a good enough answer to at least get the questioner to move on to the next topic, which clearly is the only way for him to save any face talking about the surge.
As for the other points he made.
The question of whether the war should have been started largely favors Obama, although there are still a minority who believe it was the right thing to do. Still, that is just changing the subject. And, it should be noted that McCain opposed Rumsfeld's strategy from the beginning. Who knows how the war would have turned out if McCain had his way from the beginning.
As for the perceived failure of the surge to address political reconciliation, why, then is the Iraq government now talking about us leaving, if the surge didn't significantly improve the political situation there? If you haven't noticed, there are political tensions in the US also. It was the violence that was the problem. As long as there is reduced violence, I'm content with letting the Iraqi's sort out their own political issues just as we do.
Obama alluded to, and others have explicitly stated, the argument that even McCain and Bush couldn't have hoped for the success that we've seen in the surge. I don't see any evidence of that, but even if it were true, good for them for being cautiously optimistic when they should have just been optimistic.
My advice to Obama: just admit you were wrong and get it over with. The longer you don't, the more you will be asked this question and be forced to give these sorts of awkward answers. I respect the fact that Obama stood up against the war when it was unpopular to do so. I also respect that McCain supported the surge when it was unpopular. So let's call it a draw and move on.
One might ask why I'm not calling on McCain to admit he was wrong about the war in general. The answer is that it is that McCain presumably still thinks that the war was the right thing to do, and will take the political heat for that. But Obama admits that the surge worked, but still defends his vote against it. It's the fact that Obama wants to have it both ways that bothers me. I'd respect his opinion more (although I would disagree with it) if he contended that the surge didn't work. At least then he would be consistent.
"If you watched the Republican National Convention over the last three days, you wouldn't know that we have the highest unemployment in five years because they didn't say a thing about what is going on with the middle class.
"They spent a lot of time talking about John McCain's biography, which we all honor," the Illinois senator said. "They talked about me a lot, in less than respectful terms. What they didn't talk about is you and what you're seeing in your lives and what you're going through, or what your friends or your neighbors are going through."
Did anyone doubt that Obama was going to say this, even before McCain gave his speech?
Since Obama apparently wasn't paying attention (and is counting on the fact that most other voters weren't either), here are some excerpts (full text is here). I apologize for the lengthy quotes, but that just makes my point that he did talk about the struggles of the middle class quite extensively:
These are tough times for many of you. You’re worried about keeping your job or finding a new one, and are struggling to put food on the table and stay in your home. All you ever asked of government is to stand on your side, not in your way. And that’s just what I intend to do: stand on your side and fight for your future.
...
I fight for Americans. I fight for you. I fight for Bill and Sue Nebe from Farmington Hills, Michigan, who lost their real estate investments in the bad housing market. Bill got a temporary job after he was out of work for seven months. Sue works three jobs to help pay the bills.
I fight for Jake and Toni Wimmer of Franklin County, Pennsylvania. Jake works on a loading dock; coaches Little League, and raises money for the mentally and physically disabled. Toni is a schoolteacher, working toward her Master’s Degree. They have two sons, the youngest, Luke, has been diagnosed with autism. Their lives should matter to the people they elect to office. They matter to me.
...
My tax cuts will create jobs. His tax increases will eliminate them. My health care plan will make it easier for more Americans to find and keep good health care insurance. His plan will force small businesses to cut jobs, reduce wages, and force families into a government run health care system where a bureaucrat stands between you and your doctor.
Keeping taxes low helps small businesses grow and create new jobs. Cutting the second highest business tax rate in the world will help American companies compete and keep jobs from moving overseas. Doubling the child tax exemption from $3500 to $7000 will improve the lives of millions of American families. Reducing government spending and getting rid of failed programs will let you keep more of your own money to save, spend and invest as you see fit. Opening new markets and preparing workers to compete in the world economy is essential to our future prosperity.
I know some of you have been left behind in the changing economy and it often seems your government hasn’t even noticed. Government assistance for unemployed workers was designed for the economy of the 1950s. That’s going to change on my watch. My opponent promises to bring back old jobs by wishing away the global economy. We’re going to help workers who’ve lost a job that won’t come back, find a new one that won’t go away.
We will prepare them for the jobs of today. We will use our community colleges to help train people for new opportunities in their communities. For workers in industries that have been hard hit, we'll help make up part of the difference in wages between their old job and a temporary, lower paid one while they receive retraining that will help them find secure new employment at a decent wage.
Some may disagree with his economic policy, but to say "he didn't say a thing" about the struggling economy is an outright lie.
Today reinforced my belief that the pundits on TV aren't paying attention to the speeches they comment on, and are not worth our time. How many times have I heard someone talk about how he said drilling would solve our problem (which is not true, he talked about wind, nuclear, and other sources of energy, and specifically said drilling would not solve the problem by itself). Another thing I'm hearing is that he didn't offer any specifics on how he would help struggling families. Apparently they weren't paying attention. Apparently conservatives weren't either. I was surprised to hear them cheer for this line:
For workers in industries -- for workers in industries that have been hard hit, we'll help make up part of the difference in wages between their old job and a temporary, lower-paid one while they receive retraining that will help them find secure new employment at a decent wage.
So there's a specific for you, but is it just me, or does this sound like a new government welfare program? I must have missed something though because conservatives don't seem to be upset by it, despite the repeated call for less government dependency throughout the convention.
I wonder how this plan will be implemented. So the government will give a check to someone working at McDonalds because they used to work at an auto plant. But the person working next to that person will not receive a check, because they never worked at the auto plant? Does that make sense?
Governor Palin, from her acceptance speech last night:
"I guess a small-town mayor is sort of like a 'community organizer,' except that you have actual responsibilities."
Palin threw a lot of jabs at Obama last night, but this was the lowest. Whether he's qualified for president or not, I admire Obama's choice to help his community when he had the opportunity. There are a lot of people out there trying to make a difference in their communities, and rally the people to a common good cause, who have now been dismissed by Palin.
I'm guessing the Obama campaign will run with this, and paint McCain and Palin as anti-community. And perhaps they deserve it for that comment.
ST. PAUL, Minn. (AP) — From the moment he stepped off his campaign plane, John McCain's arrival in the Twin Cities for the Republican National Convention was a family affair.
Greeting McCain on the tarmac at the Minneapolis-St. Paul airport were his wife, Cindy, and other family members. Also on hand were family members of Alaska Gov. Sarah Palin, who McCain chose last Friday to be his running mate.
Hugs and handshakes abounded, with two hugs between McCain and Palin's 17-year-old daughter, Bristol, and a handshake with her boyfriend, 18-year-old Levi Johnston. Palin and her husband, Todd, announced this week that Bristol is five months pregnant and that she will marry Johnston.
McCain also kissed Sarah Palin's 4-month-old son, Trig.
The politically paired families then boarded a campaign bus and headed into town.
One thing that was perhaps overlooked in the dynamics of picking a woman as VP (especially one much younger) was the inevitable media scrutiny of every celebratory hug. Or am I reading too much into this? Would this story have been different if McCain had picked a man? Should it be?
I know life isn't fair. But our societal ideal is to make it as fair as possible for our children. That is the whole idea behind public education (although it is far from fair, but that's another story), and tax funded health care programs to cover poor children.
But apparently that societal ideal has been thrown out the window by our media.
Unfortunately, teenage pregnancy is a huge problem in our society. It seems to be happening all the time. It happens to families of all political persuasions. It happens to good families as well as broken ones. And when it happens, it is an extremely difficult situation with many difficult decisions to make which have life-long consequences. Of all things that we should say are a "personal matter," certainly this should be one of them.
So when I heard the news that Governor Palin's 17-year old daughter is pregnant, my heart went out to her and her family. I expected the news to be covered, of course. But watching CNN tonight I was appalled that they splashed her face on the screen several times in the midst of talking about the political implications of the situation. The story was second only to the hurricane.
She is 17 years old! Give her some privacy! Don't you think this is hard enough for her already. This is irresponsible journalism, in my opinion.
As far as the political implications, it makes no difference to me, and I don't think it will to most Americans. If a president can have an affair in the oval office itself, and still maintain his legacy and be considered by many to be an effective president, then certainly Palin's daughter's situation (which pales in comparison), shouldn't disqualify her from the VP position. To some it might however. And to those people I say, Jesus isn't running this year.
So with that, let's move on and give the girl a break.
Update: To Obama's credit, he said related to this matter: "Let me be as clear as possible... I think people's families are off-limits and people's children are especially off-limits." Of course that's what he had to say, and I believe he means it. I hope though that others (including the media) follow his lead.
This is the first of a monthly review of who was wrong in previous month. Every month I'll choose the worst wrong of the month. And maybe in the future I'll add a poll so you can choose for yourself. For now, feel free to comment.
But without further ado, the worst wrong of August was...
The media could learn something from theoretical physics.
There's a joke I've heard (in nerdy scientific circles) that goes something like this:
Questioner: "How much water is displaced when a cow is placed in a tank of water?"
Theoretical Physicist: "Well, first let's assume the cow is spherical..."
Mention the "spherical cow" to any scientists and they'll know what you are talking about. It references the attempt to over-simplify something real and complex into something that can be defined with nice well-known formulas.
I thought of this listening to several commentators on the Sunday morning talk shows, talking about how crazy it is to think that Clinton supporters will move to support McCain now that he's picked Palin as the VP. I won't bother to even link to any of them. Just listen to any of the shows and you'll hear something like this:
Moderator: "McCain clearly hopes to gain the support of some former Clinton supporters by this pick. Will that happen?"
Pundit: "Come on, that is insulting to women. Palin does not share Clinton's view on the issues. On abortion, she is pro-life."
In making this argument, the pundit is using a "spherical Clinton supporter". For one thing, he is assuming all Clinton supporters agreed with Clinton on all of the issues. This is obviously an over-simplification. People support candidates for all sorts of reasons (including experience, for example), and rarely does a citizen find a candidate which which she agrees 100%. So, while it's true that Palin disagrees with Hillary on most issues, she could still be appealing to some former Clinton supporters who were more moderate than Hillary. Hillary did well with Catholics in Pennsylvania, at least some of which I assume are pro-life, although maybe not passionately so. (Apparently questions on abortion aren't included in the democratic exit-polls, so it's impossible to know for sure, but I think it's safe to assume that not 100% of democrats are pro-choice).
Secondly, using the abortion is as the obligatory example is deceptive. Abortion, compared to other issues, is mostly black and white. Either you are pro-life or you are pro-choice. Sure, there's some gray area (late term abortion, for example), but in comparison to issues such as the economy or national security, there is not much nuance. But on issues other than abortion, there is more room for nuance. For example, Clinton wanted to tax the oil companies. Palin also supported that in her state. Sure, their overall positions on energy are very different, but it can't be characterized as completely opposing because the issue cannot be represented as a line. It is a mult-dimensional issue. Furthermore, abortion isn't really a hot issue this election cycle.
Lastly, some people supported Hillary because they felt she was the most experience candidate and strong on national security. For those people, McCain might be the second choice rather than Hillary. This point is made well here.
Of course no one is predicting that massive throngs of Hillary supporters will flock to McCain because of the Palin pick. That would indeed be insulting to women to suggest. But some minority will move to McCain, either because they like McCain (perhaps because of his experience) or else because of Palin. And in a close election, that could make the difference.
Obama, reacting to the choice of Palin for McCain's vice presidential nominee:
Today, John McCain put the former mayor of a town of 9,000 with zero foreign policy experience a heartbeat away from the presidency.
The thing that bothers me the most about this quote is that is completely skips the part about her being governor. Yes, it was only for a year and a half, but it is a year and half more than Obama's leadership experience. It seems, if Obama was attempting to be honest, he should have a least said, "Today, John McCain put the first-term governor of a small state with zero..." I would have given him credit for that, at least. But as the quote stands, it is deceptive.
The "heartbeat" part was a nice touch as well.
Apart from that, there has been much buzz about the comparison between the experience of Obama and Palin. Here's my comparison:
Obama's got:
* Being a senator for 3 years (when he started running)
* More time in state government
Palin's got:
* 1 1/2 years as a governor (which the AP sees as equivalent to being a state senator, apparently)
* Being a mayor (which was not mentioned in the final comparison in the AP article)
Like most of America, I was shocked to hear that McCain had picked Governor Sarah Palin of Alaska as his vice presidential nominee. I had pretty much assumed it was going to be Romney. I wondered, as many probably did, if it was just because she was a woman. Then, as I listened to her speech she seemed to me like a good pick. She has a good story rising up in the ranks of politics, fighting curruption on the way. She has a good looking family, with hard-working roots it appears. I was beginning to think maybe she really was the best one for the job. And then she said this:
It was rightly noted in the Denver this week that Hillary left 18,000,000 cracks in the highest, hardest glass ceiling in America. But, it turns out that the women of America aren't finished yet, and we can shatter that glass ceiling once and for all.
So it is (at least somewhat) because she is a woman after all. If I were a woman, I'd find that offensive. I didn't like it when Hillary said in the same breath that her supporters were behind her for her policies and experience, but also wouldn't it be great to have a woman as president? And I don't like it now from Governor Palin.
Some people think having a black president once and for all will prove that America is no longer racist. Some people think having a woman president will prove we are not sexist. I disagree. I think that we will show we are not racist or sexist when a black man or a woman can lose without us blaming his race or gender. When we can have women in politics and not talk about the fact that they are women, then we will have shown that we have moved passed sexism.
While I disagree with the motive, politically I think this was a wise move for McCain. I'm a realist, and so I recognize that some portion (not a majority) of Clinton supporters were supporter her at least partially because she was a woman. Call me sexist for saying it, but that's what I think. And some of those women will feel inclined to switch now, because they never were in love with Hillary's policies anyway. It also refutes the argument Hillary made this week that the Democrats are decades ahead of the Republicans on acceptance of blacks and women in politics. But while politically wise, McCain and Palin are wrong to continue the "vote for me--I'm a woman" rhetoric.
Obama, in his well-delivered speech, want's America to know that he represents the death of the politics of the past:
For 18 long months, you have stood up, one by one, and said enough to the politics of the past. You understand that in this election, the greatest risk we can take is to try the same old politics with the same old players and expect a different result. You have shown what history teaches us — that at defining moments like this one, the change we need doesn’t come from Washington. Change comes to Washington. Change happens because the American people demand it — because they rise up and insist on new ideas and new leadership, a new politics for a new time.
I'd love nothing more than if it were true.
Obama loves to point out, as he did again tonight, that McCain votes with Bush 90% of the time. This is a deceptive statistic, and it's time I called him out on it. What is not stated, and what most Americans probably don't realize, is that many votes that take place are bi-partisan. They don't get the coverage as the really divisive issues, but yes, there are some things the bluest Democrat and the reddest Republican agree on.
Here's the proof. If you asked the average American how often Obama agrees with Bush, what do you think they'd say? On average, I'd bet the number would be pretty low. The facts are that Obama agrees with Bush 40% of the time.
Of course it's no shock that McCain agrees with Bush more often than Obama. The point here though is that Obama claims to be the face of the "new politics." So the stat that is most interesting to me is that Obama agrees with the Democratic position about 97% of the time.
Of course if you agree with 100% of the Democratic position, that's not a bad thing for you. The only reason McCain's perceived partisanship is a problem is because Bush is not popular. But no matter what your political persuasion, these numbers prove that both of these men are part of the old partisan politics.
Bill Clinton, reminiscing on the good ol' days when Republicans were criticizing his lack of experience:
On cue, CNN promptly put up on the screen this (irrelevant?) fact, which was cut from the youtube video:
Fact: Clinton is one of 12 pres. nominees who were younger than 47-year-old Obama; he was 45 in 1992.
Silly Republicans. Obama isn't that young, so all this talk of lack of experience is just spin, right? Wrong. Experience is more than just age. Bill Clinton had been a governor for a decade before he was president, and attorney general before that. Obama's experience in government leadership does not compare to that.
Obama's lack of experience was no more evident than when Biden was touting Obama's qualifications later in the evening: his work as a community organizer on Chicago's south side. True, the choice to help others rather than pursue loftier careers is admirable, but there are lots of Americans who have done admirable things. (serving in the military, for example). That alone doesn't prove he's ready to be president.
Hillary Clinton reiterated her support of Barack Obama tonight. As she's done before, she went through the key issues to show that Obama's positions are very close to her positions.
Since Clinton dropped out of the primary, Democrats and pundits have argued that Clinton supporters would surely rally behind Barack Obama since he agrees with Hillary on the issues much more than McCain. Some have even argued that former Hillary supporters that now support McCain must be racist. But that begs the question: If Hillary's positions were so close to Baracks, why were they both running? Why didn't Hillary drop out when it was clear she was going to lose, if Barack would have been just as good?
They might have been close on the issues, but the issues are not all the matters. Experience also matters. Indeed, Clinton made that a focus of her primary campaign, pointing out how much more experienced she was than Obama. The Republican National Committee has now come out with an ad using her own words against Obama:
In response, Hillary wisecracked, "I do not approve that message."
What part doesn't she approve of? She did say it, didn't she? It is this type of two-faced politics that this blog was created to spotlight. Political pundits might give her a free pass, but you won't get one from me for saying something just because it was politically advantageous at the time. If you said Obama was not experienced enough for the job, stand by it or you're part of what's wrong with this country.
And shame on the media for making excuses for her ("Oh, she ran a tough primary campaign? That's politics."). A lie is a lie.
"Barack Obama sounded as though he turned over the top spot on the ticket today to his new mentor, when he introduced Joe Biden as the next president. The reality is that nothing has changed since Joe Biden first made his assessment that Barack Obama is not ready to lead. He wasn't ready then and he isn't ready now."
Background On Barack Obama's Freudian Slip
Barack Obama: "So let me introduce to you the next President -- the next Vice President of United States of America, Joe Biden!" (Barack Obama, Remarks, Springfield, IL, 8/23/08)
Ok, so I get the argument that perhaps he picked Joe Biden to be his "mentor," but relating that to this "freudian slip" seems like a stretch to me. I've been critical of the "misspeaking" defense before, but come on, everyone slips up now and then.
Well, the fact of the matter is--and the president knows this--is that if you drill offshore today, you won't have any impact at the price at the pump for 10 years, and then, it's 2 cents. We can move much quickly by releasing oil from the strategic petroleum reserve and having an impact at the pump in 10 days, in 10 days.
Her first point is debatable. Expectation of future supply does play a role in the market today. As for her second point, tapping our oil reserve is hardly a sustainable long-term strategy.
So why is--this is the oil company position, to drill offshore without any comprehensive approach to other aspects of it.
You can have a transition with natural gas. You can have a transition with natural gas. That, that is cheap, abundant and clean compared to fossil fuels. So, so there is a way to transition this instead of doing more of the same.
How long will it take to retrofit existing gas stations to serve up natural gas? How many cars today can run on natural gas? Even if car makers started making natural gas based cars today, how long would it be until those new vehicles start trickling down to poor Americans? In the meantime, how much will those poor Americans be paying to fill up their old gasoline-fueled vehicles?
McCain made a double-gaff this week. First, he jokingly says that a 5 million dollar income is rich. And then he forgot how many houses he owns (I can just hear his campaign staff smacking their foreheads). Now, Obama would be politically negligent not to jump all over these comments, but I'm not going to give him a pass just because he's doing what any other politician would do. After all, he's supposed to represent the new politics, remember?
For one thing, the 5 million thing was clearly a joke. He picked a high number to make the point that it doesn't matter (he has a bad habit of doing this), since he's not going to raise taxes on anyone.
Secondly, while I admit that not knowing how many houses you own is certainly strange, owning a lot of houses means nothing. Do you think there aren't plenty of Democrats that have a lot of assets? I seem to remember one primary contender that I think has been in the news lately.
But while jumping all over McCain's gaffs, Obama made a mini-gaff of his own. Just after this clip ends, Obama reportedly said:
But if you’re like me, and you got one house, or you were like the millions of people who are struggling right now to keep up with their mortgage so they don’t lose their home, you might have a different perspective.
Like you? Oh yes, those millions of Americans with 1.65 million dollar homes.
Wrong Rating: 1 out of 4 (spin)
(p.s. I wonder if McCain's perceived stumbling on this issue will make him less likely to pick Romney as the V.P.)
McCain does indeed want to lower the corporate tax rate for corporations (all of them, not just the big ones). You know, the same corporations the employ most of us. Yeah, they're evil. They should be taxed out of existence. You know how they're all raking in the cash in this great economy of ours.
And, contrary to what this ad implies and what the Obama campaign has been saying forever, McCain has no specific plan for lowering taxes on oil companies. The tax savings Obama sites for oil companies is simply the result of lowering the overall corporate tax rate. But if you believe Obama, you'd think McCain wanted to specifically lower the taxes on oil companies, which is not true.
The Associated Press actually has a good article outlining the issues involved:
McCain does call for a reduction in corporate taxes, from 35 percent now to 25 percent after 2014. But at least one Obama economic adviser has indicated that Obama himself might be open to a lower corporate tax rate — though not as low as McCain has recommended.
In an interview with Forbes.com last month, Jason Furman, Obama's director of economic policy, said: "He would like to cut the corporate tax rate, and it's a question that we're studying." In June, Obama also told The Wall Street Journal he might support a cut in corporate taxes. Still, Obama's economic plan aims the largest cuts toward lower-income taxpayers while McCain would give the largest tax cuts to high-income taxpayers.
The $4 billion in tax breaks for the oil companies is simply part of McCain's overall corporate tax reduction plan and does not represent an additional tax benefit. In other words, the corporate tax reduction applies to all corporations, oil companies included. Both Obama and McCain have proposed eliminating oil and gas tax loopholes.
Interesting, so Obama would also be in favor of reducing taxes on the "big corporations?" Of course I'm sure he'd find a way to exclude oil companies. We simply can't have companies being too successful in the United States. His plan would probably make companies with a high profit margin pay more taxes. Oh wait, that wouldn't work, since the profit margin of the oil companies is actually lower than many other industries.
And, according to the AP, both Obama and McCain have proposed eliminating the oil and gas tax loopholes.
McCain, responding to Obama's remarks responding to McCain's claims that Obama would rather lose the war than lose an election:
How do you say that someone would rather lose the war than lose an election, and then say that you aren't questioning his patriotism? McCain wants to have it both ways. He wants to attack Obama using inflammatory claims, but paint himself as above the fray at the same time. I'm not buying it.
"Americans across our country are hurting, as we all know, because of the cost of energy. Gas prices are through the roof. Energy costs have seeped into our grocery bills, making it more expensive to feed our families. Now as we prepare for the winter, it's time for us to be more serious about our home heating oil needs. ... And that means we need to start drilling offshore, at advanced oil rigs like this one."
Umm... winter comes every year. When was it time to become more serious about offshore drilling? I don't know, maybe 10 years ago, when McCain opposed it?
"Our nation is sending $700 billion overseas every year to countries that don't like us very much. When I'm president that's going to stop. We're going to achieve energy independence, and we're going to do it by using every resource at our disposal to get the job done, including new offshore drilling."
I think the term "flip-flop" is thrown around way too much these days. People should be allowed to change their mind when the situation changes. In fact, this is how McCain has defended his change of heart. He claims his new position is based on two facts:
1) The cost of gas has increased, which is an immediate hardship on American families, and the cost is likely to continue increasing.
2) We are sending $700 billion overseas to "countries that don't like us very much." That money should be staying here.
I agree with both of those points. The problem, though, is that those facts aren't really different than they were 10 years ago. Did anyone seriously think that oil prices weren't going to increase? Did anyone seriously think that there wasn't going to be more demand, forcing us to import more oil from foreign countries? These realities are not new. McCain should have recognized them 10 years ago, and advocated more drilling then. So I don't let McCain off the hook with the "I change my mind when the facts on the ground change" excuse. This seems like a classic example of "lack of judgment" if I ever saw one. Of course, the democrats claiming, "it won't help for 10 years" isn't any better, considering they opposed it 10 years ago too!